GoMacro MacroBar Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip
Organic purists who prioritize whole food ingredients and clean certifications above protein content
Quest Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Protein Bar
Macro-focused gym-goers who prioritize protein-to-calorie ratio above ingredient purity
Score Comparison
Pricing & Features
Making Your Decision
When to Choose GoMacro MacroBar Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip
Organic purists who prioritize whole food ingredients and clean certifications above protein content
GoMacro is the gold standard for ingredient purity in the protein bar space. USDA Organic, C.L.E.A.N. certified, and made entirely from whole food ingredients. The trade-off is modest protein (11g) and higher sugar from organic sources. If ingredient quality matters more than macros, this is the bar to beat.
Strengths
- USDA Organic and C.L.E.A.N. certified with all whole food ingredients
- Zero artificial sweeteners, sugar alcohols, or preservatives of any kind
- Organic peanut butter and brown rice protein from traceable sources
Limitations
- Only 11g protein per bar — among the lowest in this comparison
- Higher sugar content (~10g) compared to low-sugar competitors
- Premium price at ~$3.21/bar makes it one of the most expensive options
When to Choose Quest Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Protein Bar
Macro-focused gym-goers who prioritize protein-to-calorie ratio above ingredient purity
Quest dominates on macros — 21g protein, <1g sugar, widely available everywhere. But it achieves this with sucralose AND erythritol, earning the lowest ingredient purity and sugar profile scores in our comparison. If you only count macros, Quest is king. If ingredient quality matters, look elsewhere.
Strengths
- Industry-leading macros with 21g protein and less than 1g sugar per bar
- Milk protein isolate and whey isolate provide high bioavailability and complete amino acids
- Widely available in virtually every grocery store, gas station, and gym in the country
Limitations
- Contains BOTH sucralose and erythritol — double artificial sweetener and sugar alcohol penalty
- Heavily processed ingredient list with numerous additives beyond the protein
- Sucralose is one of the most controversial artificial sweeteners in health-conscious circles
