Which is better, Garden of Life Sport Organic Protein Bar Peanut Butter Chocolate or Pure Protein Chocolate Peanut Butter Bar?

Garden of Life Sport Organic Protein Bar Peanut Butter Chocolate scores higher overall with 8.0/10. Garden of Life Sport Organic Protein Bar Peanut Butter Chocolate edges ahead with a higher overall score.

Garden of Life Sport Organic Protein Bar Peanut Butter Chocolate vs Pure Protein Chocolate Peanut Butter Bar Comparison 2026

Garden of Life Sport Organic Protein Bar Peanut Butter Chocolate Wins

Winner

Garden of Life Sport Organic Protein Bar Peanut Butter Chocolate

8.0

Certified-organic athletes who need NSF for Sport verification in a protein bar

Buy on Amazon

Pure Protein Chocolate Peanut Butter protein bar

Pure Protein Chocolate Peanut Butter Bar

5.2

Budget buyers who want the most protein per dollar and are not concerned about artificial sweeteners

Buy on Amazon

David NakamuraHealth & Wellness Writer

Score Comparison

Criteria

Garden of Life Sport Organic Protein Bar Peanut Butter Chocolate

Pure Protein Chocolate Peanut Butter Bar

Overall Score

8.0

5.2

Ingredient Purity

Evaluates overall cleanliness of the ingredient list. Penalizes artificial sweeteners (sucralose, acesulfame K), sugar alcohols (erythritol, maltitol, sorbitol), artificial preservatives, artificial colors/flavors, and seed oils. Rewards whole food ingredients, organic certification, and minimal processing.

8.5

3.0

Protein Source Quality

Assesses the quality and bioavailability of protein sources. Ranks: grass-fed whey isolate > whey concentrate > egg white > collagen > multi-source plant blend > single-source plant protein. Considers amino acid completeness and digestibility (PDCAAS score).

7.5

Sugar & Sweetener Profile

Analyzes total sugar content and sweetener types. Penalizes high sugar (>8g), sugar alcohols, and artificial sweeteners. Rewards natural sweeteners (dates, honey, monk fruit) and low total sugar while maintaining palatability.

7.0

3.5

Macronutrient Balance

Evaluates protein-to-calorie ratio, fiber content (3g+ preferred), and overall macronutrient distribution. Higher protein per calorie scores better. Balanced fat content and adequate fiber are preferred.

8.5

Certifications & Testing

Third-party certifications including USDA Organic, Non-GMO Project Verified, NSF Certified for Sport, Informed Sport, Kosher, B Corp status, and independent lab testing verification.

9.5

4.0

Taste & Texture

Based on aggregated consumer reviews, expert taste tests, and texture assessments across major review sources. Considers flavor variety, chewiness vs. chalkiness, and overall enjoyment.

7.0

Transparency

Full ingredient disclosure, clear allergen labeling, sourcing information (e.g., grass-fed, organic origin), nutritional claim accuracy, and company transparency practices.

8.0

4.0

Pricing & Features

Specification

Garden of Life Sport Organic Protein Bar Peanut Butter Chocolate

Pure Protein Chocolate Peanut Butter Bar

Price

$2.33/bar

$1.33/bar

Package Price

$28 for 12 bars

$16 for 12 bars

Making Your Decision

When to Choose Garden of Life Sport Organic Protein Bar Peanut Butter Chocolate

Certified-organic athletes who need NSF for Sport verification in a protein bar

Garden of Life Sport is the most heavily certified protein bar in this comparison — NSF for Sport, USDA Organic, and Non-GMO Verified. The 20g organic plant protein is impressive for a certified bar. Texture is denser than whey-based competitors, which is typical of plant protein bars.

Strengths

Triple certified: NSF Certified for Sport, USDA Organic, and Non-GMO Project Verified
20g organic plant protein per bar — highest among certified organic options
Trusted brand with pharmaceutical-grade manufacturing standards

Limitations

Dense, chewy texture typical of organic plant protein bars
~6g sugar per bar is moderate — not the lowest available
Collection-level product page makes finding specific flavors difficult online

When to Choose Pure Protein Chocolate Peanut Butter Bar

Budget buyers who want the most protein per dollar and are not concerned about artificial sweeteners

Pure Protein wins on value — 20g protein at ~$1.33/bar is the cheapest protein per gram in this comparison. The whey blend is effective. But sucralose and likely artificial flavors earn it some of the lowest ingredient scores. This is the bar for those who count macros and dollars, not ingredient labels.

Strengths

Best value in this comparison at ~$1.33/bar with 20g protein per bar
Whey protein blend provides good bioavailability and complete amino acids
Widely available at nearly every grocery store, convenience store, and pharmacy

Limitations

Contains sucralose — a controversial artificial sweetener penalized in our scoring
Likely contains artificial flavors alongside the sucralose sweetening
Minimal transparency about sourcing, testing, or manufacturing practices

Ready to Get Started?

Garden of Life Sport Organic Protein Bar Peanut Butter Chocolate

Score: 8.0

Buy on Amazon Read Full Review

Pure Protein Chocolate Peanut Butter Bar

Score: 5.2

Buy on Amazon Read Full Review