Rent Manager Wins
Winner
Rent Manager logo

Rent Manager

8.1

Mid-to-large property managers with diverse, mixed-use portfolios who need deep customization and enterprise-grade accounting

VS
Avail logo

Avail

6.8

First-time DIY landlords with fewer than 10 units who value simplicity and Realtor.com listing syndication

Sarah Chen
Sarah Chen

Score Comparison

Criteria
Rent Manager
Avail
Overall Score
8.1
6.8
Core Features
9.5
7.0
Accounting & Reporting
9.5
5.5
Ease of Use
6.0
8.5
Pricing & Value
6.0
8.0
Tenant & Owner Portals
8.0
7.0
Integrations
8.0
5.5
Scalability
9.5
5.5
Customer Support
8.5
6.0

Pricing & Features

Specification
Rent Manager
Avail
Starting Price
$200/mo
Free / $9/mo
Free Tier
Pricing Model
Subscription
Freemium

Making Your Decision

Rent Manager logo

When to Choose Rent Manager

Mid-to-large property managers with diverse, mixed-use portfolios who need deep customization and enterprise-grade accounting

Rent Manager is one of the most feature-rich and flexible property management systems available, backed by nearly four decades of development. Its power comes at the cost of a dated UI and a steep learning curve. Best for experienced operators managing diverse property types who need depth over simplicity.

Strengths

  • Extremely deep feature set with 450+ built-in reports and full double-entry accounting
  • Handles all property types — residential, commercial, self-storage, manufactured housing, and short-term stays
  • Dedicated customer success teams, Rent Manager University training, and comprehensive knowledge base
  • Longest track record in the industry (37+ years) with continuous modern development

Limitations

  • Interface feels dated with more clicks than necessary for everyday tasks
  • Steep learning curve — requires significant training investment for new teams
  • Add-on fees and per-user charges make total cost less transparent than advertised
Avail logo

When to Choose Avail

First-time DIY landlords with fewer than 10 units who value simplicity and Realtor.com listing syndication

Avail is a solid, beginner-friendly platform with a generous free tier and strong listing reach via the Realtor.com ecosystem. However, the per-unit pricing model makes it progressively less economical as your portfolio grows, and the lack of a mobile app is a notable gap.

Strengths

  • Backed by Realtor.com with automatic listing syndication to 20+ rental sites
  • Strong free plan with state-specific lease templates, Autopay, and rent collection
  • Clean, simple interface designed for first-time DIY landlords
  • Tenant screening with TransUnion credit, background, and eviction reports

Limitations

  • Per-unit pricing ($9/unit/month) gets expensive as portfolios grow — 10 units is $90/month
  • No dedicated mobile app — web-only access frustrates landlords managing on the go
  • Inconsistent customer support quality with limited response channels

Ready to Get Started?