Ultima Replenisher
Daily hydration seekers who want zero-sugar, zero-calorie electrolytes with clean ingredients
Propel Powder Packets
Budget shoppers who want the cheapest zero-calorie electrolyte option available
Score Comparison
Pricing & Features
Making Your Decision
When to Choose Ultima Replenisher
Daily hydration seekers who want zero-sugar, zero-calorie electrolytes with clean ingredients
Ultima Replenisher is one of the cleanest zero-calorie electrolyte options with no sugar, artificial sweeteners, or fillers. The very low sodium makes it better for daily hydration than athletic performance. The wide flavor variety and affordable bulk pricing add practical appeal.
Strengths
- Zero sugar, zero calories, zero artificial ingredients — one of the cleanest formulas available
- Contains 6 electrolytes plus trace minerals and support vitamins
- Available in stick packs and bulk canisters with 10+ flavor options
Limitations
- Uses stevia and citric acid which some find creates a slightly tart aftertaste
- Sodium content (55mg) is very low — insufficient for heavy sweating or athletic use
- Plant-based colors may cause slight staining of water bottles over time
When to Choose Propel Powder Packets
Budget shoppers who want the cheapest zero-calorie electrolyte option available
Propel is the budget king at $0.35/serving, but you get what you pay for. Artificial sweeteners, colors, and minimal electrolyte content make it the lowest-quality option in this comparison. It's essentially flavored water with a small electrolyte boost — fine for light use, but serious hydration needs require more.
Strengths
- Cheapest per-serving cost in this comparison at ~$0.35/serving
- Zero sugar and zero calories — good for calorie-conscious hydration
- Ubiquitous retail availability in grocery stores, gas stations, and pharmacies
Limitations
- Contains sucralose and acesulfame potassium (artificial sweeteners)
- Very low electrolyte content — only 160mg sodium and minimal other minerals
- Artificial colors and flavors with minimal ingredient transparency
