Stewart Freeze Dried Raw Beef Liver
Owners who want the purest single-ingredient treat with maximum transparency
Old Mother Hubbard Classic Original Mix
Budget-conscious owners who want a simple, no-nonsense everyday biscuit
Score Comparison
Pricing & Features
Making Your Decision
When to Choose Stewart Freeze Dried Raw Beef Liver
Owners who want the purest single-ingredient treat with maximum transparency
Stewart Freeze Dried Beef Liver is as clean as it gets — one ingredient, freeze-dried, nothing else. The transparency score is a perfect 10 because there is literally nothing to hide. Dogs go absolutely wild for the smell and taste. The premium price and crumbly texture are the only downsides.
Strengths
- Single ingredient — 100% beef liver with nothing added
- Freeze-dried process preserves nutrients without cooking or additives
- Extremely high palatability — dogs find the aroma irresistible
Limitations
- Premium price at $36 for a 14oz container
- Messy and crumbly — pieces break apart in pockets and bags
- Rich liver can cause digestive upset if overfed
When to Choose Old Mother Hubbard Classic Original Mix
Budget-conscious owners who want a simple, no-nonsense everyday biscuit
Old Mother Hubbard delivers a straightforward oven-baked biscuit with recognizable ingredients at an unbeatable price. The crunchy texture provides mild dental benefit, though the wheat and corn base means it is not ideal for grain-sensitive dogs. A solid everyday treat for the price.
Strengths
- Simple, recognizable ingredients with no artificial preservatives or colors
- Oven-baked crunchy texture helps with dental maintenance
- Excellent value at under $9 for a 20oz bag
Limitations
- Contains wheat flour and corn meal — not grain-free
- Higher calorie density per biscuit than soft training treats
- Limited protein variety in the original mix formula
