Stewart Freeze Dried Raw Beef Liver Wins
Winner
Stewart freeze dried raw beef liver single ingredient treats

Stewart Freeze Dried Raw Beef Liver

9.0

Owners who want the purest single-ingredient treat with maximum transparency

VS
Full Moon Chicken Jerky human-grade dog treats package

Full Moon Chicken Jerky

8.5

Owners who want human-grade, transparent ingredients in a jerky format

David Nakamura
David Nakamura

Score Comparison

Criteria
Stewart Freeze Dried Raw Beef Liver
Full Moon Chicken Jerky
Overall Score
9.0
8.5
Ingredient Quality
9.5
9.0
Calorie & Nutritional Profile
8.0
7.5
Ingredient Transparency
10.0
9.0
Safety Record
9.0
9.0
Palatability & Acceptance
9.5
9.0
Value Per Treat
7.0
7.5

Pricing & Features

Specification
Stewart Freeze Dried Raw Beef Liver
Full Moon Chicken Jerky
Price
$2.58/oz
$0.75/oz
Package Price
$36.09 for 14 ozs
$17.99 for 24 ozs

Making Your Decision

Stewart Freeze Dried Raw Beef Liver logo

When to Choose Stewart Freeze Dried Raw Beef Liver

Owners who want the purest single-ingredient treat with maximum transparency

Stewart Freeze Dried Beef Liver is as clean as it gets — one ingredient, freeze-dried, nothing else. The transparency score is a perfect 10 because there is literally nothing to hide. Dogs go absolutely wild for the smell and taste. The premium price and crumbly texture are the only downsides.

Strengths

  • Single ingredient — 100% beef liver with nothing added
  • Freeze-dried process preserves nutrients without cooking or additives
  • Extremely high palatability — dogs find the aroma irresistible

Limitations

  • Premium price at $36 for a 14oz container
  • Messy and crumbly — pieces break apart in pockets and bags
  • Rich liver can cause digestive upset if overfed
Full Moon Chicken Jerky logo

When to Choose Full Moon Chicken Jerky

Owners who want human-grade, transparent ingredients in a jerky format

Full Moon sets the standard for ingredient transparency — USDA human-grade chicken with minimal, readable ingredients. You can see and smell the quality. The jerky format is less convenient than pre-sized training treats, but the ingredient quality and safety record are top tier for the mid-range price.

Strengths

  • USDA-certified human-grade chicken — the only human-grade jerky in this comparison
  • Single protein source with minimal ingredients you can actually read
  • Made in the USA with full ingredient traceability

Limitations

  • Higher price per ounce than standard treats
  • Jerky strips need to be torn into smaller pieces for training use
  • Higher calorie density than small training treats

Ready to Get Started?

Stewart freeze dried raw beef liver single ingredient treats

Stewart Freeze Dried Raw Beef Liver

Score: 9.0
Full Moon Chicken Jerky human-grade dog treats package

Full Moon Chicken Jerky

Score: 8.5