Jiminy's Crunchy Treats Original Recipe
Eco-conscious owners and dogs with common protein sensitivities
Blue Buffalo BLUE Bits Chicken
Training sessions where you need a soft, flavorful treat without grains
Score Comparison
Pricing & Features
Making Your Decision
When to Choose Jiminy's Crunchy Treats Original Recipe
Eco-conscious owners and dogs with common protein sensitivities
Jiminy's is the most innovative treat in this comparison — cricket protein delivers complete amino acids with a fraction of the environmental impact of traditional meat. The novel protein is a genuine option for allergy-prone dogs. Not every dog will love the taste immediately, but the sustainability story and ingredient quality are compelling.
Strengths
- Cricket protein is highly sustainable — 2,000x less water than beef production
- Novel protein source ideal for dogs with common protein allergies
- Clean ingredient list with no artificial preservatives or fillers
Limitations
- Cricket protein is unfamiliar to most dog owners — adoption hurdle
- Some dogs may reject the flavor profile initially
- Smaller 5oz bag means higher cost per ounce
When to Choose Blue Buffalo BLUE Bits Chicken
Training sessions where you need a soft, flavorful treat without grains
Blue Buffalo BLUE Bits deliver a solid mid-range training treat — real chicken first, grain-free, and soft enough for quick consumption during training. Past brand recalls ding the safety score, but the current formula is clean. Good value at $12 for a 19oz bag.
Strengths
- Real chicken as the first ingredient with DHA for brain health
- Soft, moist texture that dogs find highly appealing
- No poultry byproducts, corn, wheat, or soy
Limitations
- Blue Buffalo has had past recalls affecting brand trust
- Contains flaxseed which some dogs may have sensitivity to
- Softer texture means shorter shelf life once opened
