Too Close to Call
Garmin Forerunner 165
8.5
Runners and cyclists wanting accurate GPS and training metrics without premium prices
VS
Samsung Galaxy Watch 8
8.4
Android users wanting the best smartwatch-fitness hybrid with AI health insights
Score Comparison
Criteria
Garmin Forerunner 165
Samsung Galaxy Watch 8
Overall Score
8.5
8.4
Health Insights & AI
8.5
9.0
Sleep Tracking
8.0
8.5
Battery Life
8.8
6.5
Value for Money
8.5
7.5
Design & Comfort
8.2
9.0
Activity Tracking
9.0
8.5
App & Ecosystem
8.0
9.0
Pricing & Features
Specification
Garmin Forerunner 165
Samsung Galaxy Watch 8
Price
$250
$349
Released
20-Feb-24
25-Jul-25
Making Your Decision
When to Choose Garmin Forerunner 165
Runners and cyclists wanting accurate GPS and training metrics without premium prices
The Forerunner 165 brings Garmin's renowned GPS accuracy and training features to a more accessible price point with a stunning AMOLED screen.
Strengths
- Excellent GPS accuracy
- Beautiful AMOLED display
- Body Battery and Training Readiness
- Garmin Coach adaptive plans
Limitations
- Limited advanced analytics vs higher models
- No music storage
- Plastic case feels less premium
When to Choose Samsung Galaxy Watch 8
Android users wanting the best smartwatch-fitness hybrid with AI health insights
The Samsung Galaxy Watch 8 sets the standard for Android smartwatches with its AI Energy Score and comprehensive health tracking, though battery life remains a weakness.
Strengths
- AI Energy Score predicts daily performance
- Best Android smartwatch integration
- Comprehensive Samsung Health ecosystem
- Sleek cushion design with AMOLED display
Limitations
- Only 30-40 hour battery life
- Requires Samsung phone for full features
- No physical rotating bezel (Watch 8 Classic does)
