Too Close to Call
Garmin Forerunner 165
8.5
Runners and cyclists wanting accurate GPS and training metrics without premium prices
VS
Google Pixel Watch 4
8.5
Pixel and Android users wanting the purest Google smartwatch experience with AI features
Score Comparison
Criteria
Garmin Forerunner 165
Google Pixel Watch 4
Overall Score
8.5
8.5
Health Insights & AI
8.5
8.8
Sleep Tracking
8.0
8.5
Battery Life
8.8
6.8
Value for Money
8.5
7.8
Design & Comfort
8.2
9.0
Activity Tracking
9.0
8.2
App & Ecosystem
8.0
9.5
Pricing & Features
Specification
Garmin Forerunner 165
Google Pixel Watch 4
Price
$250
$349
Released
20-Feb-24
09-Oct-25
Making Your Decision
When to Choose Garmin Forerunner 165
Runners and cyclists wanting accurate GPS and training metrics without premium prices
The Forerunner 165 brings Garmin's renowned GPS accuracy and training features to a more accessible price point with a stunning AMOLED screen.
Strengths
- Excellent GPS accuracy
- Beautiful AMOLED display
- Body Battery and Training Readiness
- Garmin Coach adaptive plans
Limitations
- Limited advanced analytics vs higher models
- No music storage
- Plastic case feels less premium
When to Choose Google Pixel Watch 4
Pixel and Android users wanting the purest Google smartwatch experience with AI features
The Google Pixel Watch 4 shines with Gemini AI and satellite SOS, offering the most cohesive Google ecosystem experience despite average battery life.
Strengths
- Gemini AI integration for smart assistance
- Satellite SOS emergency connectivity
- Purest Wear OS experience with Google apps
- Beautiful domed display design
Limitations
- 30-40 hour battery life
- Limited to Pixel phones for best experience
- Smaller display than competitors
