Gnarly Nutrition Hydrate
Competitive athletes who need NSF certification and zero-sugar clean ingredients
Key Nutrients Electrolyte Recovery Plus
Budget-conscious daily users who want zero-calorie electrolytes with vitamin supplementation
Score Comparison
Pricing & Features
Making Your Decision
When to Choose Gnarly Nutrition Hydrate
Competitive athletes who need NSF certification and zero-sugar clean ingredients
Gnarly Hydrate checks the boxes for competitive athletes: NSF Certified for Sport, zero sugar, monk fruit sweetened, and solid electrolyte ratios. The taste won't please everyone, but the clean formula and certification make it a strong choice for anyone subject to drug testing.
Strengths
- NSF Certified for Sport — safe for competitive athletes subject to drug testing
- Zero sugar with no artificial sweeteners — uses monk fruit extract
- Good electrolyte balance with 200mg sodium, 250mg potassium per serving
Limitations
- Monk fruit taste can be polarizing — some find it has a slight aftertaste
- Less widely available in retail stores compared to mainstream brands
- Resealable bag format can clump in humid conditions
When to Choose Key Nutrients Electrolyte Recovery Plus
Budget-conscious daily users who want zero-calorie electrolytes with vitamin supplementation
Key Nutrients offers the best per-serving value in this comparison with 90 servings at under $0.50 each. The zero-sugar formula with added vitamins makes it a solid daily hydration choice, though the moderate electrolyte amounts may not suffice for heavy athletic use.
Strengths
- Outstanding value at ~$0.44/serving with 90 servings per tub
- Zero sugar and zero calories with 6 key electrolytes plus 12 vitamins
- Wide flavor variety with 10+ options including unique picks like peach mango
Limitations
- Uses stevia which can taste bitter to some people at this concentration
- Contains "natural flavors" without full disclosure of sourcing
- Electrolyte amounts per serving are moderate — may need double-scooping for intense activity
