Jiminy's Crunchy Treats Original Recipe
Eco-conscious owners and dogs with common protein sensitivities
Rachael Ray Nutrish Savory Roasters Chicken
Budget shoppers who want real chicken as the primary ingredient without artificial additives
Score Comparison
Pricing & Features
Making Your Decision
When to Choose Jiminy's Crunchy Treats Original Recipe
Eco-conscious owners and dogs with common protein sensitivities
Jiminy's is the most innovative treat in this comparison — cricket protein delivers complete amino acids with a fraction of the environmental impact of traditional meat. The novel protein is a genuine option for allergy-prone dogs. Not every dog will love the taste immediately, but the sustainability story and ingredient quality are compelling.
Strengths
- Cricket protein is highly sustainable — 2,000x less water than beef production
- Novel protein source ideal for dogs with common protein allergies
- Clean ingredient list with no artificial preservatives or fillers
Limitations
- Cricket protein is unfamiliar to most dog owners — adoption hurdle
- Some dogs may reject the flavor profile initially
- Smaller 5oz bag means higher cost per ounce
When to Choose Rachael Ray Nutrish Savory Roasters Chicken
Budget shoppers who want real chicken as the primary ingredient without artificial additives
Rachael Ray Nutrish Savory Roasters punch above their price point — real chicken first, no artificial additives, and a slow-roasted texture that dogs go crazy for. The added sugar and grain base keep it from premium territory, but for under $10 this is strong value.
Strengths
- Real chicken is the #1 ingredient — no poultry byproducts or fillers
- No artificial flavors, colors, or preservatives
- Slow-roasted texture dogs find highly appealing
Limitations
- Contains added sugar (cane molasses) for flavor enhancement
- Not grain-free — includes wheat flour and ground corn
- Softer texture does not provide dental benefit like crunchy treats
