Benebone Wishbone Wins
Winner
Benebone Wishbone bacon flavor dog chew toy

Benebone Wishbone

8.6

Moderate chewers who love flavored chew toys with an ergonomic grip shape

VS
Chuckit! Ultra Ball medium orange and blue fetch toy

Chuckit! Ultra Ball (Medium 2-Pack)

8.4

Fetch-loving dogs and owners who want a durable, high-visibility ball

David Nakamura
David Nakamura

Score Comparison

Criteria
Benebone Wishbone
Chuckit! Ultra Ball (Medium 2-Pack)
Overall Score
8.6
8.4
Durability
9.0
8.5
Safety & Materials
9.0
8.5
Enrichment Value
7.0
7.5
Construction Quality
9.0
8.5
Size Versatility
8.5
8.0
Ease of Cleaning
8.0
9.0
Value
9.0
9.5

Pricing & Features

Specification
Benebone Wishbone
Chuckit! Ultra Ball (Medium 2-Pack)
Price
$12.78
$9.95

Making Your Decision

Benebone Wishbone logo

When to Choose Benebone Wishbone

Moderate chewers who love flavored chew toys with an ergonomic grip shape

Benebone Wishbone delivers the best flavored chew experience in this comparison — real bacon is infused throughout the nylon, not just sprayed on the surface. The wishbone shape is genuinely clever, giving dogs purchase points that flat bones cannot match. Durability is excellent for moderate chewers, though power chewers should size up or consider the KONG Classic instead.

Strengths

  • Real bacon flavor infused throughout — not just a surface coating
  • Wishbone shape allows dogs to grip and chew from multiple angles
  • Made in the USA with food-grade nylon and real flavor ingredients

Limitations

  • Not intended for aggressive power chewers who can break off chunks
  • No fillable or puzzle component — purely a chew toy
  • Needs replacement when deep grooves appear (roughly every 2-3 months for moderate chewers)
Chuckit! Ultra Ball (Medium 2-Pack) logo

When to Choose Chuckit! Ultra Ball (Medium 2-Pack)

Fetch-loving dogs and owners who want a durable, high-visibility ball

The Chuckit! Ultra Ball is the definitive fetch toy — the thick natural rubber walls outlast tennis balls by months, the high bounce is perfect for active play, and the bright coloring makes it almost impossible to lose in the yard. At under $5 per ball in the 2-pack, the value is outstanding. Not designed for unsupervised chewing.

Strengths

  • High-bounce natural rubber core with thick walls outlasts standard tennis balls
  • Compatible with Chuckit! launchers for extended fetch distance
  • Bright orange and blue coloring is highly visible on grass and in water

Limitations

  • Power chewers can eventually puncture the rubber walls if left to chew unsupervised
  • Slightly smaller than standard tennis balls — may not fit all ball launchers
  • Limited enrichment value beyond fetch play

Ready to Get Started?

Benebone Wishbone bacon flavor dog chew toy

Benebone Wishbone

Score: 8.6
Chuckit! Ultra Ball medium orange and blue fetch toy

Chuckit! Ultra Ball (Medium 2-Pack)

Score: 8.4