Casper Dog Bed Wins
Winner
Casper dog bed with memory foam in gray

Casper Dog Bed

8.4

Design-conscious owners who want human-mattress-quality foam in a modern, clean aesthetic

VS
Coolaroo Original Elevated pet bed in grey

Coolaroo Original Elevated

7.7

Outdoor dogs or dogs in warm climates who need airflow and easy-clean durability

David Nakamura
David Nakamura

Score Comparison

Criteria
Casper Dog Bed
Coolaroo Original Elevated
Overall Score
8.4
7.7
Comfort & Support
9.0
6.0
Durability
8.0
8.5
Washability
8.5
9.5
Size & Fit
7.5
7.0
Material Safety
9.5
8.0
Design & Features
8.5
8.0
Value
6.0
8.5

Pricing & Features

Specification
Casper Dog Bed
Coolaroo Original Elevated
Price
$225
$38

Making Your Decision

Casper Dog Bed logo

When to Choose Casper Dog Bed

Design-conscious owners who want human-mattress-quality foam in a modern, clean aesthetic

Casper applies their human mattress expertise to dog beds, and the quality shows — premium memory foam, a durable ripstop bottom, and a clean modern design. At $225+ it is the most expensive option here, and the foam is not as thick as Big Barker for large dogs. But for design-conscious owners, the Casper brand and quality are compelling.

Strengths

  • Pressure-relieving memory foam adapted from Casper's human mattress technology
  • Machine-washable outer cover with durable ripstop bottom panel
  • Microfiber bolster rim provides 360-degree head and neck support

Limitations

  • Most expensive option in this comparison at $225+ — premium brand pricing
  • Limited to three sizes — fewer options than competitors
  • Memory foam is thinner than Big Barker — less support for very large dogs
Coolaroo Original Elevated logo

When to Choose Coolaroo Original Elevated

Outdoor dogs or dogs in warm climates who need airflow and easy-clean durability

The Coolaroo is a different category of dog bed — elevated, breathable, and virtually indestructible for cleaning purposes. Perfect for outdoor use, porches, or dogs that overheat. The trade-off is zero cushioning, so it is not the right choice for dogs with joint issues. But for durability and washability, nothing beats it.

Strengths

  • Elevated HDPE fabric allows airflow underneath — ideal for hot climates and outdoor use
  • Extremely easy to clean — just hose it off and let it air dry
  • Powder-coated steel frame is highly durable and resists rust

Limitations

  • No cushioning or foam — not suitable for dogs needing orthopedic support
  • Fabric can sag over time under heavier dogs (100+ lbs)
  • Some dogs dislike the elevated/hammock feel and prefer traditional beds

Ready to Get Started?

Casper dog bed with memory foam in gray

Casper Dog Bed

Score: 8.4
Coolaroo Original Elevated pet bed in grey

Coolaroo Original Elevated

Score: 7.7