BarkBox 2-in-1 Donut Cuddler Wins
Winner
BarkBox 2-in-1 memory foam donut cuddler dog bed

BarkBox 2-in-1 Donut Cuddler

7.3

Small to medium dogs who love to curl up and nest in a cozy donut-style bed

VS
MidWest QuietTime Bolster dog bed in gray

MidWest QuietTime Bolster

7.0

Budget-conscious owners who need a basic, easy-to-clean crate pad

David Nakamura
David Nakamura

Score Comparison

Criteria
BarkBox 2-in-1 Donut Cuddler
MidWest QuietTime Bolster
Overall Score
7.3
7.0
Comfort & Support
7.5
6.5
Durability
6.5
6.0
Washability
7.5
8.0
Size & Fit
7.0
7.5
Material Safety
7.0
7.0
Design & Features
8.0
6.5
Value
8.0
9.0

Pricing & Features

Specification
BarkBox 2-in-1 Donut Cuddler
MidWest QuietTime Bolster
Price
$46
$25

Making Your Decision

BarkBox 2-in-1 Donut Cuddler logo

When to Choose BarkBox 2-in-1 Donut Cuddler

Small to medium dogs who love to curl up and nest in a cozy donut-style bed

The BarkBox 2-in-1 is a clever design — flip between a donut cuddler and a flat mat depending on your dog's mood. The memory foam base provides real comfort and the raised rim creates a cozy nesting spot. Limited to smaller dogs and hand-wash only are the main trade-offs.

Strengths

  • Converts between donut cuddler and flat mat — two beds in one design
  • Memory foam base provides comfort while the bolster rim offers security
  • Soft, plush cover feels cozy and dogs tend to nest in the donut shape

Limitations

  • Only available in smaller sizes — not suitable for large or giant breeds
  • Cover is hand-wash recommended, which is less convenient than machine wash
  • The 2-in-1 mechanism can loosen over time with heavy use
MidWest QuietTime Bolster logo

When to Choose MidWest QuietTime Bolster

Budget-conscious owners who need a basic, easy-to-clean crate pad

The MidWest QuietTime Bolster is the most affordable option here and does the basics well — soft surface, machine washable, fits standard crates. But the thin fill means it is not ideal for dogs that need real orthopedic support. A solid starter bed or crate liner at a hard-to-beat price.

Strengths

  • Extremely affordable entry point at just $25 — lowest price in this comparison
  • Fully machine washable and dryer safe for easy cleaning
  • Available in multiple sizes to fit standard MidWest crates

Limitations

  • Thin polyester fill offers minimal orthopedic support for older or larger dogs
  • Fabric and stitching are not built to withstand heavy chewing
  • Limited shape retention — flattens noticeably after a few months of use

Ready to Get Started?

BarkBox 2-in-1 memory foam donut cuddler dog bed

BarkBox 2-in-1 Donut Cuddler

Score: 7.3
MidWest QuietTime Bolster dog bed in gray

MidWest QuietTime Bolster

Score: 7.0